Profit Sharing Plan

A profit sharing plan is a type of employee benefit plan in which a company shares a portion of its profits with its employees. This shared profit is typically distributed among employees based on a predetermined formula or criteria defined by the company. Profit-sharing plans serve as a financial incentive for employees, motivating them to contribute to the company's success.

What is profit sharing?

Profit sharing is a compensation system or incentive program in which a company shares a portion of its profits with its employees. Under profit sharing, employees receive a bonus or additional payment based on the company's financial performance and profitability. This additional payment is typically in addition to their regular wages or salaries.

Here are the key characteristics and aspects of profit sharing:

Distribution of profits:Profit sharing involves the distribution of a portion of the company's profits among its employees. The amount distributed is determined by a predetermined formula or criteria established by the company.
Motivation and incentive: The primary purpose of profit sharing is to motivate employees to work diligently and contribute to the company's success. By giving employees a direct financial stake in the company's profitability, it encourages them to be more productive and aligned with the organization's goals.
Variable payments: Profit sharing payments are variable and can vary from year to year. In profitable years, employees may receive more substantial profit-sharing bonuses, while in less profitable years, the payouts may be smaller or nonexistent.‍
Additional compensation: Profit sharing payments are in addition to an employee's regular salary or wages. They provide an extra financial reward for employees based on the company's performance.

Boost Sales Performance by 94% with Our Gamified Commission Management Software

What are different types of profit sharing plans?

There are several different types of profit-sharing plans that companies can implement to distribute a portion of their profits to employees. Each type of profit-sharing plan has its own characteristics and objectives. Here are some of the most common types:

Cash profit-sharing plan
Deferred profit-sharing plan (DPSP)
Stock-based profit-sharing plan
Combination plan
Percentage of profits plan
Age-weighted profit-sharing plan
New comparability profit-sharing plan
Integrated profit-sharing plan
Cross-tested profit-sharing plan
Performance-based profit-sharing plan

Cash profit-sharing plan: In a cash profit-sharing plan, employees receive their share of the company's profits in the form of cash bonuses. These bonuses are typically added to employees' paychecks and are subject to income tax. Cash profit-sharing plans provide immediate financial rewards to employees.
Deferred profit-sharing plan (DPSP): A deferred profit-sharing plan is designed to encourage long-term savings and retirement planning. Instead of receiving cash bonuses, employees' profit-sharing contributions are deferred and invested on their behalf. Employees typically access these funds upon retirement, disability, or other predetermined events.
Stock-based profit-sharing plan: Some companies offer profit-sharing plans in which employees receive company stock or stock options as part of their profit-sharing rewards. This type of plan aligns employee interests with the company's performance and can make employees feel like partial owners of the company.
Combination plan: A combination profit-sharing plan combines elements of both cash and deferred contributions. In these plans, a portion of the profit-sharing rewards is distributed as cash bonuses, while another portion is deferred into a retirement account or other savings vehicle. This approach provides employees with both immediate and long-term benefits.
Percentage of profits plan: Under this type of plan, a fixed percentage of the company's profits is allocated to the profit-sharing pool. The total amount distributed to employees can vary based on the company's financial performance. The percentage of profits plan does not rely on individual employee factors like salary or job position.
Age-weighted profit-sharing plan: Age-weighted profit-sharing plans take into account the age of employees as a factor in determining profit-sharing allocations. Older employees typically receive larger contributions, as they have fewer years until retirement and less time to accumulate retirement savings.
New comparability profit-sharing plan: New comparability plans allow employers to allocate profit-sharing contributions disproportionately among employees based on factors such as job classification or other criteria. This approach can be used to reward specific groups of employees, such as executives or key personnel.
Integrated profit-sharing plan: Integrated profit-sharing plans are designed to work in conjunction with Social Security benefits. The profit-sharing contributions are integrated with Social Security to provide higher benefits for employees with lower Social Security benefits.
Cross-tested profit-sharing plan: Cross-tested plans are often used by businesses with both highly compensated and non-highly compensated employees. These plans allocate contributions based on age, service, or other criteria to ensure that they meet IRS nondiscrimination requirements.‍
Performance-based profit-sharing plan: In this type of plan, profit-sharing contributions are tied to specific performance metrics or financial targets. Employees who meet or exceed these performance goals receive larger profit-sharing rewards.

What are benefits of profit sharing plan?

The benefits of profit sharing plan:

Financial reward
Motivation
Ownership mentality
Long-term savings
Retention
Positive workplace relations

Financial reward: Employees receive a portion of the company's profits as an additional source of income. This can significantly boost their overall compensation and financial well-being.
Motivation: Profit-sharing plans motivate employees to work harder, be more productive, and make decisions that contribute to the company's profitability. When employees see a direct financial benefit tied to company performance, they are often more motivated to perform at their best.
Ownership mentality: Profit-sharing fosters a sense of ownership among employees. They feel a greater connection to the company's success and may take more pride in their work and contributions.
Long-term savings: Deferred profit-sharing plans (DPSPs) encourage employees to save for retirement or other long-term financial goals. These plans help employees build financial security for the future.
Retention: Companies that offer profit-sharing plans may experience improved employee retention. Employees who receive profit-sharing rewards are often more loyal to the company and less likely to seek employment elsewhere.
Positive workplace relations: Profit sharing can lead to better relations between employees and management. Employees may feel valued and recognized for their contributions, contributing to a positive work environment.

What are examples of profit sharing plan?

The examples of profit sharing are:

Southwest Airlines: Southwest Airlines is known for its profit-sharing program, which is one of the most generous in the airline industry. Employees receive a percentage of the company's annual profits as part of their compensation. The program has contributed to the company's positive corporate culture and employee satisfaction.
Publix Super Markets: Publix, a supermarket chain, has a successful profit-sharing plan for its employees. The plan, known as the Publix Stockholder program, allows eligible employees to become company shareholders over time. This ownership stake is funded through profit-sharing contributions and helps create a sense of ownership among employees.
American Fidelity Assurance Company: This insurance and financial services company has a robust profit-sharing program that rewards employees based on company performance. The program includes both cash bonuses and contributions to employees' retirement accounts.
Lincoln Electric: Lincoln Electric, a manufacturer of welding equipment and supplies, has a unique profit-sharing program known as the "Incentive Management Program." Employees receive bonuses based on achieving certain performance targets, and the program has been a key factor in the company's success and low turnover rates.

What are limitations of profit sharing plan?

Some of the limitations of profit sharing plan:

Dependence on company profits
Lack of predictability
Concentration of risk
Inequity among employees
Administrative complexity
Lack of employee control

Dependence on company profits: Profit-sharing plans are directly tied to the financial performance of the company. When the company experiences a downturn or lower profits, profit-sharing payouts may be reduced or eliminated altogether. This can lead to disappointment and frustration among employees who were expecting additional income.
Lack of predictability: Employees may find it difficult to predict their profit-sharing bonuses accurately. The variable nature of these payments can make financial planning and budgeting more challenging for employees.
Concentration of risk: Employees' retirement savings may become concentrated in the performance of the company's stock if the profit-sharing plan includes stock-based rewards. This concentration can pose risks, especially if the company's stock performs poorly.
Inequity among employees: Depending on the design of the profit-sharing plan, some employees may receive significantly larger bonuses than others, leading to perceptions of inequity within the organization. This can potentially harm morale and teamwork.
Administrative complexity: Establishing and managing a profit-sharing plan can be administratively complex and costly for employers. Compliance with tax and regulatory requirements, record-keeping, and communication with employees require careful attention.‍
Lack of employee control: Employees have no control over the company's financial performance, which directly impacts their profit-sharing rewards. This lack of control can be frustrating for employees who may feel that their efforts alone do not determine their bonuses.

What are risk involved in profit sharing plan?

Some of the overall risks involved in profit-sharing plans:

Dependence on company performance
Volatility in employee compensation
Concentration of risk
Inequity among employees
Administrative complexity

Dependence on company performance: Profit-sharing plans are directly tied to the financial performance of the company. When the company experiences a downturn or reduced profits, profit-sharing contributions and payouts may decrease or be eliminated. This can lead to disappointment and frustration among employees who were expecting additional income.
Volatility in employee compensation: Profit-sharing payments can be highly variable from year to year, making it challenging for employees to predict their total compensation accurately. This can create financial uncertainty and affect employees' ability to budget and plan for their financial future.
Concentration of risk: If the profit-sharing plan includes company stock as part of the rewards, employees' retirement savings may become heavily concentrated in the performance of that stock. If the company's stock underperforms, employees may experience significant financial losses.
Inequity among employees: Depending on the profit-sharing plan's design, some employees may receive significantly larger bonuses than others. This can lead to perceptions of inequity within the organization and potentially harm morale and teamwork.
Administrative complexity: Establishing and managing a profit-sharing plan can be administratively complex and costly for employers. Compliance with tax and regulatory requirements, record-keeping, and communication with employees require careful attention.

Employee pulse surveys:

These are short surveys that can be sent frequently to check what your employees think about an issue quickly. The survey comprises fewer questions (not more than 10) to get the information quickly. These can be administered at regular intervals (monthly/weekly/quarterly).

One-on-one meetings:

Having periodic, hour-long meetings for an informal chat with every team member is an excellent way to get a true sense of what’s happening with them. Since it is a safe and private conversation, it helps you get better details about an issue.

eNPS:

eNPS (employee Net Promoter score) is one of the simplest yet effective ways to assess your employee's opinion of your company. It includes one intriguing question that gauges loyalty. An example of eNPS questions include: How likely are you to recommend our company to others? Employees respond to the eNPS survey on a scale of 1-10, where 10 denotes they are ‘highly likely’ to recommend the company and 1 signifies they are ‘highly unlikely’ to recommend it.

Based on the responses, employees can be placed in three different categories:

Promoters
Employees who have responded positively or agreed.
Detractors
Employees who have reacted negatively or disagreed.
Passives
Employees who have stayed neutral with their responses.

How does profit sharing work?

Profit sharing works as:

1. Determine eligibility

The company establishes eligibility criteria to determine which employees are eligible to participate in the profit-sharing program. Common eligibility criteria may include factors such as length of service, job status, or other criteria specified by the company.

2. Calculate total profits

The company calculates its total profits for a specific period, such as a fiscal year. These profits are determined after accounting for all expenses, including operating costs, taxes, and other financial obligations.

3. Establish the formula

The company establishes a formula or criteria for distributing the profit-sharing pool among eligible employees. The formula can vary and may include one or more of the following factors:

Percentage of salary: A common approach is to allocate a percentage of each eligible employee's base salary or wages. For example, the company may decide to allocate 10% of an employee's annual salary.
Length of service: Some companies use an employee's length of service as a factor in the formula. Longer-serving employees may receive a higher percentage of the profit-sharing pool.
Position or job level: The formula may differentiate between employees based on their job positions or levels within the organization. Higher-level employees may receive a larger share.
Performance metrics: In some cases, companies may incorporate performance metrics or individual performance evaluations into the formula. Employees who meet or exceed performance targets may receive larger bonuses.

4. Calculate individual payments

Once the formula is established, the company calculates the profit-sharing payment for each eligible employee. Here's a simplified formula as an example:

Profit-Sharing Payment = (Percentage of Salary) x (Employee's Annual Salary)

Let's say an employee's annual salary is $50,000, and the company has allocated 10% of their salary for profit sharing:

Profit-Sharing Payment = 0.10 x $50,000 = $5,000

In this example, the employee would receive a profit-sharing payment of $5,000 for that specific period.